| 1/2026 | The Bookbinder | Pip Williams | Kay Sharpley |
| 12/2025 | Open Read | | Team Vote |
| 11/2025 | Project Hail Mary | Andy Weir | Nicole McMahon |
| 10/2025 | We Used to Live Here | Marcus Kliewer | |
| 9/2025 | All the Colors of the Dark | Chris Whitaker | Mary Keenan |
| 8/2025 | The Great Believers | Rebecca Makkai | |
| 7/2025 | The Third Pole | Mark Synnott | Jenny McCarty Finch |
| 6/2025 | The Day the World Came to Town: 9/11 in Gander, Newfoundland | Jim Defede | Julie Conlon Bertolino |
| 5/2025 | The Charm School | Nelson DeMille | Beth Florence |
| 4/2025 | Listen for the Lie | Amy Tintera | Kay Sharpley |
| 3/2025 | First Lie Wins | Ashley Elston | Karen Coronado |
| 2/2025 | The Rom-Commers | Katherine Center | Sarah Bartels |
| 1/2025 | The Women | Kristin Hannah | Cynthia Marble Svajda |
| 12/2024 | The Santa Suit / The Spirit of Christmas | Mary Kay Andrews / Debbie Macomber | Team Vote |
| 11/2024 | The Dictionary of Lost Words | Pip Williams | Lee Wolford |
| 10/2024 | The Frozen River | Ariel Lawhon | Kay Sharpley |
| 09/2024 | Divine Rivals | Rebecca Ross | Julie Bertolini |
| 08/2024 | The Five: The Untold Lives of the Women Killed by Jack the Ripper | Hallie Rubenhold | Sandra Sawyer |
| 07/2024 | The Boys in the Boat | Daniel James Brown | Liz Sorensen |
| 06/2024 | The Heaven and Earth Grocery Store | James McBride | Mary Keenan |
| 05/2024 | The Kite Runner | Khaled Hosseini | Sheila Daley |
| 04/2024 | The Block Party | Jamie Day | Carolyn Sees |
| 03/2024 | Into the Wild | Jon Krakauer | Suzannah Elsherbini |
| 02/2024 | Bitter Is the New Black | Jen Lancaster | Sandy Griner |
| 01/2024 | Verity | Colleen Hoover | Kendall Castles |
| 12/2023 | Emma | Jane Austen | Sarah Bartels |
| 11/2023 | Distant Shores | Kristin Hannah | Liz Sorensen |
| 10/2023 | Lessons in Chemistry | Bonnie Garmus | Sandy Gartin |
| 09/2023 | The Girl on the Train | Paula Hawkins | Sarah Bartels |
| 08/2023 | Remarkably Bright Creatures + Luncheon | Shelby Van Pelt | Laura Webber |
| 07/2023 | West with Giraffes | Lynda Rutledge | |
| 06/2023 | Going Home + Author Visit | Alissa Karen Shirah | Sandy Fink |
| 05/2023 | The President Is Missing | Bill Clinton & James Patterson | Sheila Daley |
| 04/2023 | The All-Girl Filling Station’s Last Reunion | Fannie Flagg | Liz Sorensen |
| 03/2023 | Timeline | Michael Crichton | Lee Wolford |
| 02/2023 | Mistress of the Ritz | Melanie Benjamin | Julie Bertolini |
| 01/2023 | A Man Called Ove + Movie (Otto) | Fredrik Backman | Debbie Anderson |
| 12/2022 | Rebecca | Daphne du Maurier | Lee Wolford |
| 11/2022 | The Last Thing He Told Me | Laura Dave | Laura Webber |
| 10/2022 | Klara and the Sun | Kazuo Ishiguro | Ruqaiyah Syed Scruggs |
| 09/2022 | Wild | Cheryl Strayed | Sandy Griner |
| 08/2022 | The House in the Cerulean Sea | T.J. Klune | Laura Webber |
| 07/2022 | Where the Crawdads Sing + Movie | Delia Owens | Team Vote |
| 06/2022 | 28 Summers | Elin Hilderbrand | Laura Webber |
| 05/2022 | The Disappearing Act | Catherine Steadman | Karen Coronado |
| 04/2022 | The Four Winds | Kristin Hannah | Cynthia Svajda |
| 03/2022 | The Lost and Found Bookshop | Susan Wiggs | |
| 02/2022 | American Dirt | Jeanine Cummins | Carol Rosa |
| 01/2022 | The Girl with the Louding Voice | Abi Dare | Francisca Lute Lara |
| 12/2021 | Santa Cruise | Mary Higgins Clark | Mary Keenan |
| 11/2021 | Anxious People | Fredrik Backman | Terry Haire |
| 10/2021 | Before I Go to Sleep | S. J. Watson | Nicole Huff |
| 09/2021 | The Dutch House | Ann Patchett | Laura Webber |
| 08/2021 | The Alice Network | Kate Quinn | Kay Sharpley |
| 07/2021 | We Are All the Same in the Dark | Julia Heaberlin | Teresa Craig |
| 06/2021 | Mrs. Everything | Jennifer Weiner | Sandy Fink |
| 05/2021 | A Man Called Ove | Fredrik Backman | Nicole Huff |
| 04/2021 | The Silent Patient | Alex Michaelides | Terry Haire |
| 03/2021 | The Keeper of Lost Things | Ruth Hogan | Colette Harmon |
| 02/2021 | Kitchens of the Midwest | J. Ryan Stradal | Debbie Anderson |
| 01/2021 | Little Fires Everywhere | Celeste Ng | Colette Harmon |
| 12/2020 | The Christmas Train | David Baldacci | Linda Puddicombe |
| 11/2020 | The Exile | Allan Folsom | Linda Puddicombe |
| 10/2020 | The Year of Pleasures | Elizabeth Berg | Kay Sharpley |
| 09/2020 | Saving CeeCee Honeycutt | Beth Hoffman | Karen Coronado |
| 08/2020 | The Rosie Project | Graeme Simsion | Nicole Huff |
| 07/2020 | The Child Finder | René Denfeld | Stormi Ross |
| 06/2020 | All the Light We Cannot See | Anthony Doerr | Teresa Smith |
| 05/2020 | What She Left Behind | Ellen Marie Wiseman | Sandra Sawyer |
| 04/2020 | Beneath a Scarlet Sky | Mark Sullivan | Kay Sharpley |
| 03/2020 | The Single Thread | Tracy Chevalier | Debbie Anderson |
| 02/2020 | Long Road to Mercy / A Minute to Midnight | David Baldacci | Linda Puddicombe |
| 01/2020 | The Apothecary’s Daughter | Charlotte Betts | Tammy Rabey |
| 12/2019 | The Photograph | Debbie Rix | Debbie Anderson |
| 11/2019 | The Lager Queen of Minnesota | J. Ryan Stradal | Pat Morrow |
| 10/2019 | The Language of Flowers | Vanessa Diffenbaugh | Nicole Huff |
| 09/2019 | The Last Mrs. Parrish | Liv Constantine | Maribel Maldonado |
| 08/2019 | Where the Crawdads Sing | Delia Owens | Teresa Craig |
| 07/2019 | The Good Daughter | Alexandra Burt | Andrea Macaluso |
| 06/2019 | Something in the Water | Catherine Steadman | Karen Coronado |
| 05/2019 | The Little Old Lady Who Broke All the Rules | Catharina Ingelman-Sundberg | Monica Potter |
| 04/2019 | The Great Alone | Kristin Hannah | Kaylie Carlton |
| 03/2019 | The Keeper of Lost Things | Ruth Hogan | Colette Harmon |
| 02/2019 | Unshakable Hope | Max Lucado | Amanda Brown |
| 01/2019 | Ladies of Carrollton Book Club Founded | | |
Ladies of Carrollton, TX Book Club 